Coinbase takes a legal win in two lawsuits in California.
In an unprecedented development in the crypto legal sphere, the US Supreme Court ruled in favor of cryptocurrency giant Coinbase, effectively pausing two ongoing cases against the firm in California.
The decision, announced on June 23rd, is considered a historic first for the Supreme Court in the world of cryptocurrency litigation.
Did you know?
Want to get smarter & wealthier with crypto?
Subscribe - We publish new crypto explainer videos every week!
What is Yield Farming in Crypto? (Animated Explanation)
The lawsuits were brought forth by plaintiffs claiming that Coinbase failed to adequately compensate users who suffered financial losses and allegedly engaged in misleading advertising.
Coinbase countered the charges, urging the district courts to dismiss cases. The company's defense centered on the argument that users had accepted an agreement upon account creation specifying that disputes would be resolved through arbitration, not court lawsuits.
A document from the case shared by Courthouse News stated:
The sole question here is whether the district court must stay its pre-trial and trial proceedings while the interlocutory appeal is ongoing. The answer is yes: The district court must stay its proceedings.
Penned by Justice Brett Kavanaugh, the opinion gained the support of four other conservative justices, passing by a slim majority of 5–4. With the ruling, both cases will now be directed towards arbitration - a process typically less financially burdensome compared to court settling.
Despite being a clear victory for Coinbase, the decision's implications extend beyond the company, potentially influencing the cryptocurrency industry. As mentioned in the court's opinion:
When creating a Coinbase account, individuals agree to the terms in Coinbase’s User Agreement. As relevant here, the User Agreement contains an arbitration provision, which directs that disputes arising under the agreement be resolved through binding arbitration.
Currently, it remains uncertain how this decision will impact similar cases against other crypto firms.
Moreover, there's no indication yet whether this case will influence the ongoing action against Coinbase by the Securities and Exchange Commission. However, the Supreme Court’s ruling underscores the notion that existing laws can be effectively applied to cases related to the cryptocurrency industry.
The Supreme Court's historic decision in favor of Coinbase not only marks a significant victory for the company but also underscores the capacity of existing legislation to address disputes within the burgeoning cryptocurrency industry.
